How to Befriend Your Inner Critic + How to Become a “Thought Detective"

In this podcast (episode #338) and blog, I talk about our inner critic: what it is, and how to manage it.

The inner critic is that voice inside your head that is regularly telling you that you are not good enough or that you can’t do something—it constantly judges you and finds you wanting.

There’s a lot of advice out there telling us how to shut down this inner critic. But is this always helpful? As I have said many times before, what we resist, persists. The more we try to suppress something, the harder it tries to sink its fingernails into us.

We can't ever get rid of our personal fears and anxieties completely. In fact, in many cases, it can be helpful and insightful exercise to explore these feelings. What are they telling us about ourselves…about what is going on in our lives? What are these emotions pointing to? When we learn how to address and manage these feelings -- when we learn how to talk back to our inner critic -- we can turn a potentially toxic situation into an opportunity to learn and grow. 

But this doesn’t happen overnight. It takes time (around 63 days!) to reprogram your responses to your inner critic, as I discuss in detail in my latest book Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess and app Neurocycle. You have to learn how to make your inner critic your friend, but this won’t happen overnight, so remember to give yourself grace! 

Below are some tips to help you manage your relationship with your inner critic:

1. Don’t just try to silence the voice.

If we are completely honest, we cannot always control our inner critic. The harder we try to control these thoughts, the more stress we may experience, which can end up making the situation worse. We may feel like we are failing ourselves if the thoughts don’t just “go away”. 

A better strategy is to question your thoughts instead of suppressing them, as I mentioned above. If your inner critic is telling you that you will fail at something, for example, question why it is saying that. Try to find the evidence behind the thought—become a “thought detective”. Next, try to find reasons why you won’t fail. Focus on the successes you have had in the past, not just your failures. Remember the times you overcame a challenge and celebrate them!

2. See it as a protective mechanism.

It is natural for us to experience fear, especially if we have been in situations in the past that have put us under tremendous stress. Remind yourself of this when you start to hear that inner voice. Acknowledge the fear and explore its roots—be graceful and compassionate towards your past self. Then, recognize that you are no longer in that same position, and no longer have to fear that specific experience. Your past and present, although connected, are not the same. 

3. Tell it to move on.

This may sound silly, but you can respond to your inner critic in the moment with a simple thought, such as “Okay I hear you, but I don’t want to listen to this, so I am going to move on” or “No, but thank you for sharing”. Treat your inner critic like you would treat a scared child. Acknowledge the small nudges that your inner critic is sending you, but focus on your next steps to try to stop yourself going into a downward spiral. Indeed, if you acknowledge the thought as soon as it arises, you can better prevent the negative thought spiral. 

4. Take risks!

It is so easy to get into a toxic cycle where you listen to your inner critic and think you aren’t good enough. Unfortunately, this kind of thinking will only make your feelings of inadequacy and failure grow stronger, which can develop into a toxic mental habit and impact your wellbeing. 

But, if you are willing to take a risk and challenge your inner critic, you will feel your self-confidence beginning to grow, and you will learn how to discern what you should listen to and do in future situations. When you take this risk, you are essentially acknowledging your inner critic, but not allowing it to hold you back.

5. Be preemptive.

If you are prone to a lot of negative self-talk that keeps you from doing the things you want to do, start working on breaking that habit. Try to analyze and question these thoughts as they arise—make it a daily habit to be a “thought detective”. When you start analyzing these negative thoughts, you may also begin finding a common thread, pattern or trigger that you can work on. Many of the fears that come from our inner critic are not rooted in the present moment—they come from past experiences that affected us in a certain way.

6. Shift your focus.

Start trying to focus on how you want to feel and what you want to believe, rather than just what your inner critic tells you. Remember, whatever you think about the most will grow! If you focus on a thought like “I want to believe I am good enough” while you work on the root of the negative thought and build a new habit, the “I want to believe” will eventually become “I believe”! 

Get into the habit of reminding yourself that you are way more capable and way more valuable than your inner critic says you are. Remind yourself that it is possible to learn how to work with your inner critic and manage it, while still recognizing your own importance and trusting your own decisions! 

For more on managing your inner critic, listen to my podcast (episode #338), and check out my latest book Cleaning Up Your Mental Mess and app Neurocycle. If you enjoy listening to my podcast, please consider leaving a 5-star review and subscribing. And keep sharing episodes with friends and family and on social media. (Don’t forget to tag me so I can see your posts!).        

To learn more about how to manage your mental health and help others, join me at our 7th Annual Mental Health Solutions Retreat, December 2-4, 2021! The core focus of this conference is to give you simple, practical, applicable, scalable, and scientific solutions to help you take back control of your mental health, help others, and make impactful changes in your community. You will also learn how to manage the day-to-day stressors of life as well as those acute stressors that blindside us. Our goal is to address your most pressing mental health concerns, help you find answers, and equip you with the knowledge and resources you need to make the change from a life of barely surviving to one where you are thriving. Register today at!  

This podcast is sponsored by: 

BiOptimizer’s Magnesium. If we want to be healthier mentally and physically, one of the best things we can possibly do is get several hours of quality sleep every night. The brain and body heal themselves when we sleep—it really is one of the most amazing processes, even if we are not conscious when it happens! Thankfully, there are ways we can improve our sleep quality and overall health, including taking MAGNESIUM. But most magnesium supplements use only the two cheapest synthetic forms—since they’re not full-spectrum, they won’t support better sleeping habits. There are actually 7 unique forms of magnesium, and you must get ALL of them if you want to experience its calming, sleep-enhancing effects. That’s why I recommend Magnesium Breakthrough by BiOptimizers. Simply take two capsules before you go to bed and you’ll be amazed by how much better you sleep, and how much more rested you feel when you wake up! For an exclusive offer for my listeners go to and use DRLEAF10 during checkout to save 10% on your order.  

Public Goods, my preferred online goods store, which has everything you need, from natural cleaning products and foods to sustainable house goods. Receive $15 off your first Public Goods order with NO MINIMUM purchase. Just go to

BetterHelp, an amazing company that can assess your needs and match you with your own licensed professional therapist so that you can start communicating in under 48 hours! BetterHelp is not a crisis line, it’s not self-help…it is professional counseling done securely online! They also have a broad range of expertise available which may not be locally available in many areas, and their services are available for clients worldwide. Visit, and join the over 1,000,000 people who have taken charge of their mental health with the help of an experienced professional. In fact, so many people have been using BetterHELP that they are recruiting additional counselors in all 50 states! I am proud to say that this podcast is sponsored by BetterHelp, and Cleaning Up the Mental Mess listeners get 10% off their first month at 

Podcast Highlights

2:16, 5:00 What is the inner critic?

3:30 Why you shouldn’t suppress or ignore your inner critic 

4:10, 6:00, 16:00, 23:00 How to speak back to your inner critic using mind management & self-regulation  

8:20, 12:45 Getting to the root of your inner critic  

10:00, 12:00, 15:30 How to make your inner critic your friend 

11:40 The more you think about something, the more it grows! 

17:00 Managing intrusive thoughts like the inner critic  

18:00, 22:10 How to become a “thought detective” 

24:00 How to manage your inner critic 

30:10 What it means to talk back to your inner critic

This podcast and blog is for educational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. We always encourage each person to make the decision that seems best for their situation with the guidance of a medical professional.

Comments 0

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published